Sales gets all the credit for any successful business, but a good defense is just as important as a good offense. And in this metaphor, a good defense for you is cost management. Fixed overhead […]
Are Private Transfer Fees truly a threat to the free transfer of property? Some would agree. Regardless, they sure are causing a problem for title companies.
As an outsource provider in the title insurance process, we are at the forefront of current events and issues facing our industry. Recently we have been involved in the development of safe search practices surrounding Private Transfer Fees (PTF’s).
For those unfamiliar with PTF’s, developers of real estate (not exclusively residential) have placed what can only be described as a perpetual lien on entire tracts of property to assist in the recovery of development costs - particularly infrastructure outlays such as streets, sidewalks and open space.
The mastermind of these fees is Freehold Capital Partners based in New York City. They have what their company claims is a patent-pending structure to perpetually encumber future conveyances of real estate and transmit a private transfer fee, also referred to as a capital recovery fee, back to the trustee, commonly the developer or other organization specified by the developer. These fees are due and payable at each conveyance for a specified time period, commonly 99 years, and at a specified percentage of the sales price, typically 1%. Freehold, whose name is somewhat ironic, claims that their company has partnered with the owners of “hundreds of billions of dollars in real estate projects” since inception.
Why are these fees a struggle during the search process? Due to the infancy of this concept, the legal instruments securing these fees are unregulated, unstructured and often hidden in a condition or covenant-type document. The legal instrument mandating these fees is also only filed once at origination of the PTF. Common industry search practices such as searching back to the full value deed or other starting point of “good title” will result in missing these encumbrances should they have originated prior to that point in time. Also, without specifically named parties which to secure these fees (you can’t name an unknown future owner), these documents are near impossible to find in thin plants and other party name structured databases raising questions as to their viability.
The American Land Title Association has officially taken the position that these fees are a hindrance to the transfer of property. ALTA CEO Kurt Pfotenhauer has said that PTF’s “will result in increased costs of underwriting, claims, escrow services and compliance for the land title industry.” Freehold Capital Partners claims PTF’s assist in the fair apportionment of up-front costs and reduce sales prices, thus lower acquisition, interest and closing costs to each subsequent buyer.
Pros and cons aside, legislative restrictions on PTF’s are picking up steam across the country. California and Texas have limitations on these fees, and 15 states - most recently Hawaii, North Carolina and Louisiana - have completely banned the use of anything resembling a PTF. Presently, legislation is awaiting the governor’s signature in Illinois to ban PTF’s in that state as well.
As an outsource provider serving on a national level, it is interesting to see PTF procedures considered by our clients and how they vary from state to state. Until more widespread legislation is passed, perhaps on a national level as our industry lobby is pursuing, it will remain another evolving complexity facing our search process.
Sales gets all the credit for any successful business, but a good defense is just as important as a good offense. And in this metaphor, a good defense for you is cost management. Fixed overhead […]
Producing a great title product is the culmination of countless decisions. Unfortunately, for most title companies, the production process is often fragmented and disconnected. In the next episode of our Intentional Outsourcing series, D. Bello […]
In the next episode of our Intentional Outsourcing series, D. Bello CEO Jeffrey Bates discusses the importance of safeguarding your company’s vital knowledge and ensuring that it’s accessible, shareable, and easily deployed across your organization. […]
2022 In Review I don’t think anyone could have envisioned the twists and turns 2022 provided. From local to global issues, there was no shortage of unpredictable events. As Jim Collins notes in his book […]
First things first, congratulations to Deborah, the winner of our ALTA ONE Giveaway and the soon-to-be recipient of a brand-new RadPower Rover e-Bike! The D. Bello team made the short trip down south to attend […]
SAN DIEGO, Calif. – Oct. 14, 2022 – The reimagined and redesigned website of D. Bello, the leading remote workforce solution partner in the real estate land title space, has been recognized as one of […]
D. Bello’s Intentional Outsource series shares how your organization can win by deploying a title production outsourcing strategy with a purpose. In this video, we discuss the difference between growing and scaling your business. Growing […]
Our Intentional Outsourcing series shares how your organization can win by deploying a title production outsourcing strategy with a purpose. Our second episode focuses on staffing stability, a term sure to elicit strong emotions thanks […]
We sit down with Wayne Stanley & Heather Lunsford of Bowe Digital for their first airing of the new webinar series, The Full Package. As inaugural guests on the pilot episode, we share more […]
NEWPORT BEACH, Calif. – Jun. 23, 2022 – D. Bello, a leading remote workforce solution in the real estate title space, announced that it has made a donation to the American Land Title Association (ALTA) […]